too much thought before coffee
Jul. 20th, 2005 07:47 amI made the mistake of paying attention to NPR this morning, in which some sports commentator went on at great length about why the ovary-enabled teen golfer who has been competing successfully in the men's leagues should stop (in short: women will never be as good as men; women are special, beautiful magical creatures that should be seperate; it's unfair to women's sports to draw attention away by a superstar competing with men; it's a fool's errand to try to compete where a woman is bound to fail). For a bigwig at Sports Illustrated, this sexist idiot seemed painfully uneducated about developmental research and the narrowing gap between 'male' and 'female' high performance athletes over the years (a trend that's accelerating, btw). That this pissed me off should come as no surprise.
It got me to thinking. Lately, I've been diving deeply into liberal blogland, and a big chunk of that are feminist blogs. I experience some disjunct there sometimes, as well. I'll be reading along, agreeing with much that is being said, and get suddenly jolted out of the groove, confused and frustrated by the 'us' vs 'them' mentality.
I think both above situations are linked. In both cases, I think what's going is line drawing and border policing, and in each case, there is an implicit attempt to erase or overwrite me, and anyone else who does not wholly and unquestioningly endorse the binary-only paradigm. Speaking personally, it hurts me more when feminists do it, because one, they should know better, having been on the receiving end of sexist oppression, and two, every time they talk about 'men' and 'women', I know they're assigning me to the 'man' side, and have no interest in hearing otherwise.
This takes me to the point I woke up thinking about this morning; how can I live and exist as myself in a sociocultural world that refuses to believe I can exist? How can I interact with a system that I believe is unethical and unfair, but which allows no alternatives?
Like most days, I still don't have answers to these questions.
It got me to thinking. Lately, I've been diving deeply into liberal blogland, and a big chunk of that are feminist blogs. I experience some disjunct there sometimes, as well. I'll be reading along, agreeing with much that is being said, and get suddenly jolted out of the groove, confused and frustrated by the 'us' vs 'them' mentality.
I think both above situations are linked. In both cases, I think what's going is line drawing and border policing, and in each case, there is an implicit attempt to erase or overwrite me, and anyone else who does not wholly and unquestioningly endorse the binary-only paradigm. Speaking personally, it hurts me more when feminists do it, because one, they should know better, having been on the receiving end of sexist oppression, and two, every time they talk about 'men' and 'women', I know they're assigning me to the 'man' side, and have no interest in hearing otherwise.
This takes me to the point I woke up thinking about this morning; how can I live and exist as myself in a sociocultural world that refuses to believe I can exist? How can I interact with a system that I believe is unethical and unfair, but which allows no alternatives?
Like most days, I still don't have answers to these questions.